Spice I Am, Surry Hills, Sydney
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eed4a/eed4ade3b81aa0ff1c52a83139f6451c2b67e268" alt=""
It's always reassuring when things stay the same.
Consistency of quality was mentioned at Restaurant09 as one of the key drivers behind restaurant selection by customers. With a two-year gap between visits to Spice I Am, I'm always surprised to see the food is always just as good as I remembered.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c7a9/1c7a9c11f17ee43ccba8ec823fd2430a0b581645" alt=""
Bael fruit drink $4.00
and Thai iced coffee $4.00
In fact the only thing that's changed is the signage. Gone is the hanging blue and yellow sign between the two backpacker hostels. Now there's a fancy banner in silver afixed to the building, a colour that blends so much as to be almost invisible. A couple of times I've been convinced Spice I Am must have closed, until I get closer and realise it's still there, trading busily despite the lack of fanfare. Perhaps it's a ploy to get people to visit Spice I Am Restaurant!
Seating is still reasonably strict. There are no bookings taken, and when I arrive earlier than my dining companions, I'm told I must wait until everyone has arrived before I can take a seat (it's just on midday and they're less than a third full).
Finally everyone arrives and we can take our seats on the wide and squat wooden stools. The staff bustle about in their black t-shirts with the Spice I Am logo written in orange on the back. The menus look expanded in variety, particularly at lunchtime, but the prices don't seem to have gone up from two years ago.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0e78d/0e78d77bc6ced8823251d19ff4df4a0dfdf3e97d" alt=""
Thai fried rice $10.90 lunch special
Chicken fried rice with egg and Chinese broccoli
Drinks are served promptly, a bael fruit drink for the G-man and a Thai iced coffee for me. The bael fruit drink tastes like a berry cordial, its ruby-like appearance visually striking. Thai iced coffee is strong and sweet, a huge mound of ice helping to dilute its bitterness.
LJ is a man of mild tastes, a possible quandary in a Thai restaurant. He's happy with the Thai fried rice, a compressed mound of rice mixed through with shreds of fried egg and Chinese broccoli. Hidden within a strips of cooked chicken. Three fat slices of cucumber and a lemon wedge provide refreshment.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b3497/b349797584c2b109b2a3a7a9b39c8eec13a8a7a7" alt=""
Seafood pad cha (Phuket style) $12.90
Stir fried with curry paste, peppercorn (seasonal), basil and thai eggplant
The G-man is in rhapsodies over the seafood pad cha, a dish he says is not commonly found outside of his native Thailand. There's a distinct bitterness to the dish, added to by the tiny thai eggplant that look like peas but pop like bitter salmon roe pearls. It's also extremely spicy, a heat I can tolerate for a few spoonfuls but unlikely to be able to sustain for the entire dish. The G-man only laughs. More for him.
A mixture of seafood is fresh and flavoursome, the strips of scored calamari particularly tender.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/26b20/26b20d2f3544623e28302b5ec297cf840daf1fe2" alt=""
Pork pad prik king $10.90
Stir fried curry paste with green beans
sliced kaffir lime leaves and pork rind
Somehow I always end up ordering the pad prik king. It's sweet and spicy and I quietly revel in the delicacy of the kaffir lime leaves sliced so thinly they're wispy tendrils. It amazes me that the dish looks exactly the same in 2007 and 2005.
I think I know why I always succumb to this dish. It's the memory of the crispy pork rind, cubes of deep-fried pork crackling that crunch in the mouth, a contrast to the sweet and sticky curry paste and the squeak of fresh green beans.
Consistently good.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d5c2/2d5c25f5005837863591cd26c81e18161a8d2601" alt=""
View Larger Map
Spice I Am
90 Wentworth Avenue (corner Campbell St and Elizabeth St)
Surry Hills, Sydney
Tel: +61 (02) 928 00 928
Opening hours:
Open Tuesday to Sunday
Lunch 11.30am - 3.30pm
Dinner: 6.00pm - 10.00pm
BYO no corkage
Closed on Mondays
A second more upmarket version of Spice I Am can be found at:
Spice I Am Restaurant
296-300 Victoria Street
Darlinghurst, Sydney
Tel: +61 (02) 9332 2445
No BYO
Lunch: Thursday to Sunday 11.30am - 3pm
Dinner: Daily 6pm - 10.30pm
Related Grab Your Fork posts:
Spice I Am (Aug07), (Nov05)
posted by Helen (Grab Your Fork) on 8/12/2009 03:20:00 am
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2565d/2565dd2f53e29e4e869efab95f6224cc37e2019e" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/45951/459517fc402e22ca5929fc46615945aaf4f59e71" alt=""
15 Comments:
At 8/12/2009 7:29 am,
Trisha said…
Oh I didn't know there's 2 Spice I Am's in Sydney! Now I don't know which one to try out! And yes I agree... consistency is important when revisiting restaurants. Nothing more disappointing that ordering a dish that you remember to be quite good only to find a plate of changed tastes and flavours. And the pork pad prik king.. mmmmmm
At 8/12/2009 8:30 am,
Stephcookie said…
I've always believed consistency is one of the most important features of a restaurant, nothing irks me more than having a fantastic meal, raving about it, then bringing your friends to the same place and having the worst meal ever. Hehe I can see why that dish is your favourite, so much fatty pork goodness!
At 8/12/2009 9:25 am,
Yas said…
Hmmm I love Spice I am! We recently had a confused dinner plan - Me waiting in Surry hills my friends waiting there in Kings Cross :(
I love their soft shell crab + papaya salad!
At 8/12/2009 12:59 pm,
clekitty said…
I definitely agree about consistency being important when revisiting restaurants. Nothing worse than getting a bunch of friends together to go somewhere that you've had really good food only to find that day that the food was sub standard. I loved your description of the last dish... porky goodness!
At 8/12/2009 4:15 pm,
Anonymous said…
I am a new fan of your blog! It really is one of the best and more informative and interesting foodblogs around! Well done. :)
Will be referring to your blog for great eateries when we visit Sydney!
Darian
At 8/12/2009 11:46 pm,
Implosion said…
I'm with you Helen
I love the original Spice I Am in Surry Hills. I love that there are funky little designer furniture stores everywhere you look in the neighbourhood.
LOOOVE the yum neu and will continue to do so! :)
At 8/13/2009 12:05 am,
Anonymous said…
I haven't been Spice I am yet but I soo want to goo! Haven't had thai in agggeessss and the sound of pork rind cubes and crackling is win!
At 8/13/2009 12:45 am,
Helen (Grab Your Fork) said…
Hi Trisha - The Surry Hills version is much cheaper but the seating is limited and you can't make reservations. If you check the website, you can make a comparison on menu and prices :)
Hi Stephcookie - Consistency is important. I hadn't quite realised that I always order the pad prik king, but mmm it's so good I can't help myself.
Hi Yas - Oh no, that sounds like a comedy of errors! I haven't had their soft shell crab salad yet - will have to investigate on my next visit!
Hi clekitty - It is disappointing when your expectations of a meal fall short from what you're used to. The pad prik king is very good. Pork goodness indeed!
Hi Darian - Thank you so much for your lovely comment. There are plenty of great eats in Sydney - hope you're starting a list of places to conquer!
Hi Implosion - Surry Hills is such a cosmopolitan suburb. I do prefer the prices of the Surry Hills outlet but I'm also more appreciative of the relaxed atmosphere too.
Hi FFichiban - Oh you must get to Spice I Am soon! I think you will like the pad prik king :)
At 8/13/2009 10:32 am,
Forager said…
I somehow always ending up working around the corner from Spice I Am - so I am familiar with and love the flavours. But I have to say the higher prices and shrinking portion sizes over the years has been disappointing. Having said that I am a fan of the duck red curry when it's available. Haven't heard the best about the upmarket Spice I am in Darlinghurst so I haven't been game to check it out yet..
At 8/13/2009 1:20 pm,
Betty @ The Hungry Girl said…
I haven't tried Spice I Am yet, probably because I'm so close to Newtown which is so populated with Thai restaurants, and so cheap :) But I agree, consistency is definitely the key!
At 8/14/2009 12:03 am,
Helen (Grab Your Fork) said…
Hi Forager - A Spice I Am regular! I haven't tried the red duck curry - will have to look out for it. I think I'll always prefer to go to the cheaper version and eat twice as much for the same price :)
Hi Betty - I find that Thai restaurants in Newtown are a little pricey these days? I usually prefer the city, like I-San City or Thainatown. I think everyone treasures consistency!
At 8/14/2009 6:10 pm,
Simon Leong said…
love spice i am. one of the better thai eateries in sydney i think.
At 8/15/2009 6:58 pm,
Helen (Grab Your Fork) said…
Hi Simon Food Favourites - I think we're spoilt for choice in Sydney. I do love the little Thai eateries bordered by Goulburn, Campbell and Pitt Streets though.
At 10/12/2009 10:17 pm,
krangsquared said…
The dish that I always end up ordering when I can't decide is the Nam Kao Tod, a crispy rice and pork salad. I've never seen it anywhere else, and fell in love with it first time we tried it. I even took a menu of Spice I Am with us when we went to Phuket and was asking around if they knew about that dish. No luck, mainly because - as I just found out - it's from Northern Thailand! Duh.
At 10/13/2009 2:06 pm,
Helen (Grab Your Fork) said…
Hi krangsquared - Crispy rice and pork salad? Why haven't I ordered this already?! Maybe because it's listed under the salads :) Sounds amazing. Must keep an eye out for it the next time I'm there.
Post a Comment
<< Home